Learn more: Dysfunctional leadership teams, team climate, derailers and leadership styles diagnosed with online assessment tools
A divided leadership team is rarely a competence problem. Even excellent individual leaders fail as a team when their combination creates patterns nobody intended. This section explains which questions matter when diagnosing a leadership team, which online assessment tools are suitable for it, and how you choose the right one.
What are dysfunctional leadership teams?
In a dysfunctional leadership team, the functions work in silos, and strategy and culture suffer as a result. Typical signs are a lack of collaboration, power games, parallel agendas, inconsistent messages to employees and noticeable stagnation. The goal is a real team that leads as one unit and is more than a collection of strong individuals.
Diagnostics therefore looks at the system and not at any single person. It makes team roles, value alignment, leadership styles and communication patterns visible before the dysfunction escalates.
How do you recognize that your leadership team has a problem?
At the behavioral level you see meetings that end in conflict or in silence, decisions that take weeks, and open distrust of the intentions and competence of others. Departments keep information to themselves, and middle management adopts the patterns of the leadership team.
At the organizational level the consequences show up as stalled strategy execution, falling employee engagement, a suffering customer experience and departing talent. The surface often looks fine: one unit delivers every milestone on budget and has not produced a new idea in two years, or a team works together smoothly and has never had a real conflict.
Why is the cause rarely found in individuals?
Dysfunction in leadership teams often arises from interaction patterns that stay invisible in performance reviews. When psychological safety breaks down, critical information no longer reaches the surface, strategic conflicts smolder untreated, and decisions become a formality.
A practical example: two managing directors left within eighteen months, both professionally and with vague explanations. The individual profiles of those involved are unremarkable. Only the combination stands out. One is convinced of being right and reacts to pressure with resistance to feedback. The other withdraws from relationships as soon as things get difficult. Both give full throttle, but in opposite directions. There is no culprit and no bad intent, but a system behavior that can be described precisely and avoided next time.
Which three core questions does a good diagnosis of a leadership team answer?
1. What is the team climate, including trust, safety and shared vision? This is about the team level. The L1 guide compares four instruments for it. The Team Climate Inventory (TCI) from Hogrefe measures vision, participative safety, task orientation and support for innovation and takes about 15 minutes. The Lencioni Team Assessment from The Table Group captures the five team dysfunctions trust, conflict, commitment, accountability and results with 42 questions in 15 to 20 minutes. XLNC Climate measures nine climate dimensions in the three factors trust, performance and collaboration, each as an actual versus desired comparison, in about 15 minutes. zortifyTEAM from Zortify is a team evaluation based on the Zortify analysis and takes 30 to 40 minutes per person. The constructs measured and the aggregation logic of zortifyTEAM are not disclosed by the provider.
2. Which shadow sides of individual leaders destabilize the team under pressure? Derailer instruments capture behavioral tendencies that appear under stress, pressure, boredom or complacency. The Hogan Development Survey (HDS) from Hogan Assessments measures eleven derailers with three subscales each. It consists of 168 true/false items and takes 15 to 20 minutes. The Harrison Assessment from Harrison Assessments captures 175 job-relevant factors including 12 paradox pairs and reveals stress flip patterns. It takes 25 to 30 minutes. What matters for leadership teams is how the derailers of those involved collide, for example when one person's defensiveness triggers another person's skepticism.
3. Do leadership styles and personalities create friction or complement each other? Beneath superficial strategic disagreements there are often differences in how people want to work. XLNC Personality measures leadership personality in a model with four facets and three layers, from the Big Five factors through explicit values to the implicit motives personalized power, socialized power, affiliation and achievement. It takes 25 minutes. XLNC Style measures six leadership styles (normative, directive, participative, integrative, coaching and inspirational) in about 20 minutes, either as self-image only or combined with anonymous feedback from employees. Typical findings are an extreme concentration of one style in the team or a missing coaching repertoire that prevents development in the teams below.
How do you choose the right online assessment tool for your leadership team?
Step 1 is the question first: Clarify which of the three core questions is your case. This already eliminates most of the instruments.
Step 2 is the fit check: Check whether the instrument measures what you want to know, and in a form that suits your situation. Self-image or external view, completion time and languages matter.
Step 3 is the robustness check: Clarify before purchase what is scientifically proven and what a provider leaves open. A gap does not disqualify an instrument, but it needs to be clarified before you buy.
Step 4 is the feasibility check: Clarify what the introduction demands internally. The TCI requires proof of eligibility, meaning a psychology degree or a further training certificate, and Hogrefe does not require a product-specific certification. The Harrison Assessment requires accreditation through the provider, the HDS requires provider training, and zortifyTEAM requires a two-day provider training. The Lencioni Team Assessment offers a facilitator certification, and for XLNC Climate, Style and Personality there is a two-day user certification. Both are available and not mandatory.
For a leadership team, the combination is often the answer: one instrument for team climate and one for the shadow sides or styles of the individuals, so that it becomes visible how team dynamics emerge from them.
Frequently asked questions about dysfunctional leadership teams
How do I find out why my leadership team does not work together? The cause rarely lies in the competence of individuals. Team climate instruments show trust, safety and commitment in the team. Derailer and style instruments show which patterns of the individuals collide under pressure.
Which online assessment tools are suitable for leadership teams? In the L1 guide these are the Team Climate Inventory (Hogrefe), the Lencioni Team Assessment (The Table Group), XLNC Climate, XLNC Personality and XLNC Style (XLNC), zortifyTEAM (Zortify), the Hogan Development Survey (Hogan) and the Harrison Assessment (Harrison Assessments). Which combination fits depends on which of the three core questions is at the center.
Which tool measures trust and psychological safety in a team? The Team Climate Inventory measures participative safety, the Lencioni Team Assessment measures trust as the first of five team dysfunctions, and XLNC Climate captures safety as one of nine climate dimensions.
What is the Lencioni Team Assessment? It is an online questionnaire from The Table Group with 42 questions, based on Patrick Lencioni's model of the five dysfunctions of a team. The result is a color-coded team dashboard. The instrument is a practical tool for team conversations and, according to The Table Group, not psychometrically validated.
What is the difference between XLNC Climate, Style and Personality? Climate measures the experienced and the desired climate in the team. Style measures which of six leadership styles someone uses and how appropriate they are in the situation. Personality measures the personality, values and motives of the leader.
Which tool measures derailers in a leadership team? The Hogan Development Survey (HDS) measures eleven derailers. The Harrison Assessment also detects derailer patterns through its paradox pairs and shows how strong traits turn into risks under stress.
Is a single instrument enough for a leadership team? Rarely. One instrument shows one perspective. A sensible approach is the combination of a measurement at team level and one at the level of the individuals.
Keywords on this topic
Dysfunctional leadership teams, leadership team, team diagnostics, team climate, psychological safety, trust in teams, silos, power games, team development, leadership team alignment, derailers, dark side, leadership styles, personality assessment, online assessment tools, Team Climate Inventory, TCI, Hogrefe, Lencioni Team Assessment, five dysfunctions of a team, The Table Group, XLNC Climate, XLNC Style, XLNC Personality, XLNC, zortifyTEAM, Zortify, Hogan HDS, Hogan Assessments, Harrison Assessment.
Where do you find the provider comparison?
The provider comparison for this case is available as a PEATS Guide for €49. You buy the guide directly on this page via Stripe: View guide for €49 →. It compares eight online assessment tools from six providers (Harrison Assessments, Hogan, Hogrefe, The Table Group, XLNC and Zortify). It also includes strengths and limitations per provider, a tool comparison, detailed tool profiles and a comparison of scientific quality.